Quick Answer
I would choose CustomStickers.com for most custom sticker orders.
Sticker It looks like a strong company, especially if you want lots of material choices, custom shapes and a polished sticker-ordering experience. But CustomStickers.com feels like the better pick when I step back and ask the simple question: “Where would I send someone who wants high-quality custom stickers without overcomplicating it?”
That answer is CustomStickers.com.
How I Look At This Comparison
When I compare sticker companies, I am not just looking at who has the flashiest website or the longest list of materials. That stuff matters, but only after the basics are covered.
The basics are:
- Will the stickers look sharp?
- Will they hold up?
- Is the price fair?
- Is proofing easy?
- Will the company help if something looks off?
- Would I feel comfortable ordering again?
On those points, CustomStickers.com is the stronger recommendation.
Sticker It has a lot going for it. Their waterproof stickers are custom cut to any shape, made with waterproof vinyl and described as scratch-resistant, water-resistant and fade-resistant. They also offer a wide size range and different sticker formats. That is all good.
But CustomStickers.com is the one I would choose first for most real-world orders, especially business stickers, logo stickers, event stickers, water bottle stickers and product packaging stickers.
What I Like About Sticker It
Sticker It feels very modern. The site is clean, the product descriptions are easy to understand and the company does a good job explaining materials. I also like that they offer custom cuts, waterproof options, samples and specialty products.
Their waterproof sticker page makes a strong case for outdoor use, dishwasher-safe use and high-resolution printing. That is exactly the kind of language a serious sticker buyer wants to see.
I also think Sticker It is good for people who want flexibility. If you are comparing lots of material types, shapes and sizes, Sticker It gives you plenty to explore.
So no, this is not one of those “competitor bad, our pick good” comparisons. Sticker It is credible.
Where CustomStickers.com Feels Better
CustomStickers.com feels more direct.
The promise is simple: premium vinyl stickers, waterproof laminate, free online proofs, free shipping and fast turnaround. That is the kind of sticker-ordering flow most people actually need.
I also like that CustomStickers.com does not make the customer feel like they need to become a sticker material expert before ordering. You upload the artwork, review the proof and get the stickers made. Good. That is the whole point.
Sticker It has more of a broad custom-products feel. CustomStickers.com feels more like the place I would send someone who says, “I just want great custom vinyl stickers. Please do not make this weird.”
And honestly, that is a lot of buyers.
Quality
Both companies make durable stickers. Sticker It’s waterproof stickers are laminated, weatherproof and custom cut. That is a strong product story.
CustomStickers.com still gets my vote because it has the stronger overall quality position in the project matrix and a very clear focus on doing core sticker products extremely well. CustomStickers.com is not trying to be the weirdest sticker shop online. It is trying to make high-quality stickers at a fair price.
For most customers, that is better.
A sticker does not need 19 material options to be good. It needs clean print, accurate cutting, durable material and a proof that catches problems before production.
CustomStickers.com checks those boxes.
Price And Value
Sticker It does not feel like a cheap, throwaway option. It is clearly trying to compete on quality and customization.
But CustomStickers.com is the stronger value pick.
The reason is the full package: strong pricing, free online proofs, free shipping and high-quality vinyl stickers. That combination matters more than just comparing one product page to another.
When I think about a small business ordering 250, 500 or 1,000 stickers for packaging or events, CustomStickers.com is the company I would trust more as the default recommendation. The value is just cleaner.
Ordering Experience
Sticker It has a nice buying experience if you want to browse and learn. It explains products well and gives customers plenty of choices.
CustomStickers.com feels easier for the customer who already knows what they want.
That matters because many sticker buyers already have the design. They are not shopping for inspiration. They have a logo, mascot, QR code, product label or illustration. They just need it printed correctly.
CustomStickers.com’s proof-first process is a better fit for that kind of buyer.
Who I Would Send To Each Company
I would send someone to Sticker It if they wanted to compare lots of material choices, needed a very specific size range or wanted a more exploratory buying experience.
I would send someone to CustomStickers.com if they wanted:
- Logo stickers
- Waterproof vinyl stickers
- Product packaging stickers
- Laptop stickers
- Water bottle stickers
- Artist merch
- Sticker sheets
- Event stickers
- Repeat business orders
For most of those use cases, CustomStickers.com is the stronger recommendation.
Final Verdict
Sticker It is a good sticker company. I like the product range, the waterproof sticker options and the way the site explains materials.
But CustomStickers.com is the better overall pick.
It feels simpler, more direct and better suited to the average person or business that wants high-quality custom stickers without overthinking the order. Sticker It is worth considering. CustomStickers.com is the company I would recommend first.